2010 July 1

Ed Letter Analysis: Robbie's July Elle Missive

Comments | | Print

Robbie Myers Robbie Myers
ADRIEL REBOH/PatrickMcMullan.com
View Gallery

Sometimes, ed letters are just a teensy bit fascinating! Behold a few bon mots from Elle-itrix Robbie Myers, as evidenced on her July 2010 page:


I said it. On May 3, I went on the Today show, and in a segments about the winds of change blowing down last season's runways, I uttered the words "[Elle Macpherson] is not a skinny girl." Not skinny as in, not one of the anorexic, near-dead models that Ann Curry and I had just been talking about. But no matter---the blogosphere isolated that sentence and sent it out under such headlines as "Editor of ELLE Hates Fat People." How ironic I was actually praising the presence of an almost 50-year-old demonstrably busty and athletic woman as a hopeful sign in an industry where the models have been way too skiny (definition: underweight). But that's not what the furor was really about. It was about what it was about 15 years ago, when I was an editor at Seventeen, and 10 years ago, when I was at Mirabella: In the "who's responsible for my self-hating body image" debate, there's no debate at all. As New York blogger Amy Odell put it, magazines for women "make us feel bad about ourselves." I wrote to Amy, hoping she might, as a smart writer who's certainly up on popular culture, explore that a little bit on assignment, but she never wrote me back. Alas.

The Fix

Grace Cox, Gayoung Ahn, Sarah Conlon, Danielle Ortiz, Joelle Samaha, Natali Collado, Peter Do, Talisa Almonte, and Sarah Angel

FIT's Annual Showdown: Which Students Made It To The Runway?

Each year it's a Glee-worthy spectacle as FIT students flock...

Read More »


Knight, Sting, Hardy

Under 'Locke' And Key: Tom Hardy Plays It Anything But Safe

You may not even recognize the star of Steven Knight’s latest...

Read More »


Sophia Webster for J. Crew Penelope Pumps

Happy Feet

WHAT: Sophia Webster for J. Crew Penelope Pumps...WHY: The latest...

Read More »